2015年考研暑假必读文章:Lest We Forget or Lest We Remember?



2014-7-21 11:07

  Lest We Forget or Lest We Remember?

People remember emotionally charged events more easily than they recall the quotidian. A sexual encounter trumps doing the grocery shopping. A mugging trumps a journey to work. Witnessing a massacre trumps pretty well anything you can imagine.

That is hardly surprising. Rare events that might have an impact on an individual's survival or reproduction should have a special fast lane into the memory bank-and they do. It is called the a2b-adrenoceptor, and it is found in the amygdala, a part of the brain involved in processing strong emotions such as fear. The role of the α2b-adrenoceptor is to promote memory formation-but only if it is stimulated by adrenaline. Since emotionally charged events are often accompanied by adrenaline secretion, the α2b-adrenoceptor acts as a gatekeeper that decides what will be remembered and what discarded.

However, the gene that encodes this receptor comes in two varieties. That led Dominique de Quervain, of the University of Zurich, to wonder if people with one variant would have better emotional memories than those with the other. The short answer, just published in Nature Neuroscience, is that they do. Moreover, since the frequencies of the two variants are different in different groups of people, whole populations may have different mixtures of emotional memory.

The reason Dr de Quervain suspected the variants might work differently is that the rarer one looks like the commoner one when the latter has a memory-enhancing drug called yohimbine attached to it. His prediction, therefore, was that better emotional memory would be associated with the rarer version.

And that did, indeed, turn out to be the case in his first experiment. This involved showing students photographs of positive scenes such as families playing together, negative scenes such as car accidents, and neutral ones, such as people on the phone. Those students with at least one gene for the rarer version of the protein (everyone has two such genes, one from his father and one from his mother) were twice as good at remembering details of emotionally charged scenes than were those with only the common version. When phone- callers were the subject; there was no difference in the quality of recall.

That is an interesting result, but some of Dr de Quervain's colleagues at the University of Konstanz, in Germany, were able to take it further in a second experiment. In fact, they took it all the way along a dusty road in Uganda, to the Nakivale refugee camp. This camp is home to hundreds of refugees of the Rwandan civil war of 1994.

In this second experiment the researchers were not asking about photographs. With the help of specially trained interviewers, they recorded how often people in the camp suffered flashbacks and nightmares about their wartime experiences. They then compared those results with the α2b-adrenoceptor genes in their volunteers. As predicted, those with the rare version had significantly more flashbacks than those with only the common one.

Besides bolstering Dr de Quervain's original hypothesis, this result is interesting because only 12% of the refugees had the rarer gene. In Switzerland, by contrast, 30% of the population has the rare variety-and the Swiss are not normally regarded as an emotional people.

Whether that result has wider implications remains to be seen. Human genetics has a notorious history of jumping to extravagant conclusions from scant data, but that does not mean conclusions should be ducked if the data are good. In this case, the statistics suggest Rwanda may have been lucky: the long-term mental-health effects of the war may not be as widespread as they have been in people with a different genetic mix. On the other hand, are those who easily forget the horrors of history condemned to repeat them?


witness /'witnis/

【文中释义】 n.影响,作用



【文中释义 】adj.充满感情的,(气氛)紧张的


discard /dis'ka:d/

【文中释义】n. 品种,种类


【大纲全义】v.猜想;怀疑;察觉 n.嫌疑犯 adj.可疑的

enhance / in'ha:ns/






quotidian n.每天发生的事 amygdala n.扁桃体
adrenaline n.肾上腺素 commoner n.平民
flashback n.例叙,闪回 yohimbine n.育亨宾



这不足为奇。对于那些可能影响个体生存和繁衍的不寻常事件,它们理应有一个能够优先进入人的记忆库的快速通道,而事实也是如此—这个快速通道叫做α 2b肾上腺素受体,是在人的扁桃体中发现的。扁桃体是人大脑中处理强烈情绪(如恐惧)的部分。α 2b肾上腺素受体所扮演的角色是促进记忆的形成,但必须是在它受到肾上腺素的刺激之后。由于引起情绪很大波动的事件通常伴随着肾上腺素的分泌,α 2b肾上腺素受体就像看门人一样要决定记住哪些事而舍弃哪些事





在这第二个实验中,研究者们没有使用图片。在经过专门训练的调查人员的帮助下,他们记录了难民们脑海中战时情景闪回的次数,以及关于战时经历的噩梦的次数。然后,他们将记录结果与研究对象中所携带的α 2b肾上腺索受体基因进行了比较。正如之前所预计的一样,那些带有少见变体基因的难民所经历的记忆闪回次数,比起只有常见变休基因的难民要多得多。